Tony's Review of The Call of Cthulhu

The Call of Cthulhu by H.P. Lovecraft is a haunting journey into cosmic horror that tests the boundaries of human knowledge and sanity. Published in 1928, this story has left an indelible mark on horror literature, introducing readers to terrifying, unknown forces beyond comprehension. Lovecraft crafts a narrative that feels more like an unearthing of buried truths than a conventional tale, as it unfolds through mysterious records, ancient cults, and the chilling visions of those who have glimpsed the horrors of the cosmos. In Lovecraft’s world, true terror lies in what humanity can never hope to understand. This is a running theme in most of his works and why we remember him for cosmic horror.

At the core of this short story is the discovery of the ancient being Cthulhu, a monstrous entity slumbering in the depths of the ocean. Lovecraft introduces us to Francis Wayland Thurston, who pieces together the account through cryptic documents and witness reports, tracing cult worshippers of the ancient god and sailors who encounter unexplainable horrors at sea. Thurston’s curiosity—one that mirrors our own—leads him to a deeply unsettling conclusion. Lovecraft doesn’t rely on conventional scares; instead, he builds a creeping, existential dread, making readers feel they’re glimpsing something forbidden and unspeakable.

One of Lovecraft’s most distinctive achievements in The Call of Cthulhu is his world-building, steeped in ancient lore and the cryptic existence of elder gods. The atmosphere is dark, mysterious, and otherworldly, drawing readers into a reality where humanity is merely a speck in a vast, indifferent cosmos. Lovecraft’s elaborate descriptions amplify the terror of the unknowable, prompting readers to question the fragility of their own sense of reality. With each revelation, Lovecraft heightens the story’s cosmic dread.

However, The Call of Cthulhu can be dense and demanding. Lovecraft’s arcane style, with its intricate, archaic language, creates an atmosphere of unease, though it may slow the pace for some. The story is less about conventional plot twists or character development, focusing instead on immersing the reader in a world of mounting dread. This may challenge those seeking a fast-paced horror tale. Yet for readers who value the buildup of atmosphere and philosophical unease, the dense prose strengthens the story's chilling impact.

While Lovecraft himself considered this story "middle of the road," I would call it must-read. The Call of Cthulhu isn’t a traditional horror story; it’s an unforgettable journey into the terrifying unknown. Lovecraft’s work invites readers to confront cosmic mysteries, offering no answers but haunting, existential questions. For those ready to move beyond conventional scares and venture into the depths of cosmic horror, this story delivers a chilling experience. I do recommend it as a first Lovecraft read.